More than 4,800 first-home buyers who purchased with a 5% deposit over the past year are now in negative equity, according to REA Group economist Luc Redman — up from 1,143 in September and just 87 in July. Western Australia carries 32% of that national total despite representing only 11% of households that received the government guarantee, a gap widening as the RBA cash rate sits at 4.85% following its fifth 2026 hike.

That figure represents 7.9% of all first-home buyers who used the scheme over the past 12 months. Strip out the most recent September quarter — where price movement has been less pronounced — and the share climbs to 10.2%. Against the full housing market it remains a small slice, under 1% of new loans written over the past year. But it concentrates almost entirely in one cohort: younger, lower-income buyers who had the least time to build equity before prices at the affordable end of the market began falling faster than their deposits could absorb.

For broader market context, see World Property Forum international property intelligence.

REA Group's Negative Equity Count Triples in Two Months

The jump from 1,143 to 4,808 between September and November is the headline figure agents working first-home buyer campaigns need to understand. REA Group's analysis ties the acceleration directly to repayment pressure: based on preliminary September sales, the typical household buying the median-priced home is now spending an estimated 36.9% of its gross income on repayments — just shy of the 1989 record of 37.5%. That repayment share has moved in lockstep with the RBA's rate path, and it compounds the problem for buyers who entered the market with minimal deposits.

The federal government's expansion of the 5% deposit scheme in October 2025 removed income caps and allocated unlimited places. Uptake has been significant: the scheme now accounts for at least 52% of first-home buyer loans over the past 12 months, up from 25% before expansion. REA Group's analysis describes the effect as a "bring-forward" in demand — shortening the time needed to save, increasing competition below the relevant threshold caps, and bidding up prices in exactly the segment of the market now falling fastest.

Western Australia's Disproportionate Exposure vs Victoria's Buffer

More than a fifth — 22% — of first-home buyers in Western Australia who used the scheme are currently estimated to be in negative equity. REAStats suburb data illustrates why the state is bearing this weight unevenly. Perth's entry-level stock has been hit hardest even as prestige pockets stay firm: Nedlands holds a $2.2 million median with 15% annual growth and a 15-day sales cycle, while Mandurah — the more affordable WA entry point — sits at a $550,000 median with 10.5% growth, according to REAStats suburb data. The split shows WA's downturn is concentrated in the price band where 5% deposit buyers transact, not across the state's full market.

Victoria tells a different story. The state accounts for the largest share of guarantees since expansion — 34% — yet remains underrepresented in current negative equity estimates. REA Group attributes this to the $950k threshold cap, which has pushed Victorian scheme users toward higher-income areas where price falls have been slower. REAStats data on Dandenong — a $680,000 median, 2.3% annual growth, 40 days on market — shows a Victorian entry-tier suburb moving at a fraction of WA's growth rate, which has limited the equity erosion seen in Perth's comparable price band.

Western Australia represents around 11% of households that received a government guarantee, but accounts for 32% of national households now in negative equity — a disproportionate share tied to Perth's accelerated downturn and a resources-linked economy where iron ore prices are down roughly 15% year to date.

What This Means for Agents Working Entry-Level Listings

Agents campaigning in sub-$900,000 markets now carry a disclosure and expectation-management burden that didn't exist eighteen months ago. REAStats data shows Port Macquarie clearing at 46% with a 48-day sales cycle and Liverpool at 60.5% with a 38-day cycle — both markets where recent first-home buyers transacted heavily under the expanded scheme. Compare that to Randwick's 73.5% clearance rate and Surry Hills' 73%, where established buyer equity and tighter supply have kept conditions firmer. Agents relisting a 5% deposit purchase from the past twelve months in a market like Dandenong or Port Macquarie may be negotiating with a vendor who owes more than the home is now worth — a conversation that requires more documentation, more patience with buyer finance clauses, and more realistic price guides than agents needed during the scheme's initial uptake.

The 5% Deposit Scheme's Mechanics Behind the Numbers

Understanding why this cohort is exposed requires understanding how the scheme itself works. Removing income caps and allocating unlimited places in October 2025 meant demand that would otherwise have been spread over several years arrived at once, competing for the same stock below threshold price caps. Investors were active in the same price bands prior to the federal budget's tax changes, adding further upward pressure before conditions reversed. For readers assessing whether the scheme suits their own purchase timeline, REAStats' guide to first home buyer schemes in Australia breaks down how the Home Guarantee Scheme interacts with stamp duty exemptions and the First Home Super Saver Scheme — context relevant to any buyer weighing a low-deposit entry against the equity risk REA Group has now quantified.

What the Data Signals Near Term

REA Group's own assessment is that negative equity "remains largely a paper problem" until households face financial stress — and the Reserve Bank's financial stability review has noted these risks as low for now. But the trajectory from 87 to 1,143 to 4,808 across three data points in four months is not a plateau. For agents, the practical implication is straightforward: campaigns in entry-level WA suburbs and comparable national price bands now require upfront equity conversations with vendors who bought in the past eighteen months. For buyers considering the 5% deposit scheme today, the Mandurah-versus-Dandenong divide shows that state and suburb selection inside the scheme matters more than the guarantee itself. Vendors in this position should expect longer negotiations, and agents who can document a client's equity position early will manage both outcomes and reputational risk more effectively than those who wait for a buyer's finance clause to surface the problem at contract stage.

Further reading/context