NSW premier Chris Minns confirmed on 16 November 2026 that underquoting fines of up to $110,000 — or three times an agent's commission, whichever is greater — will be paused for up to a year, one day before the laws were due to take effect, according to The Guardian. Sydney home values have fallen 10.1% from their 2026 peak, according to Cotality data cited in the report, and Minns said agents in his south Sydney electorate of Kogarah flagged the laws would be unworkable in a falling market. The backdown comes as REAStats records Sydney's auction clearance rate at 70.8% against a national benchmark of 68.8%, with the RBA cash rate sitting at 4.85%.
The 11th-Hour Reversal
The changes, passed in June and modelled on laws already operating in Victoria, were due to ban NSW agents from advertising a property below a written offer previously rejected by the seller. Fines ran as high as $110,000 or three times commission. Minns told reporters the legislation had assumed prices would keep rising, calling the conflict with a softening market an "unforeseen consequence," and stressed it was not the fault of sellers or agents that prices are dropping.
For broader market context, see WealthWatchPro macro and interest rate analysis.
The reversal is awkward for fair trading and corrections minister Anoulack Chanthivong, who as recently as 1 November had praised the reforms as putting "the hammer down on underquoting." His later statement pivoted to argue the laws were drafted "at a different time and in a different economic and housing market." The about-face is one of several the Minns government has made in recent weeks, alongside a rollback of takeaway cup plastics rules, as Labor faces pressure from One Nation — polling at 26% of the primary vote in NSW per an October Resolve poll — ahead of the March state election.
Why the Timing Matters for Clearance Rates
Underquoting enforcement centres on exactly the conditions NSW is now navigating: a cooling market in which vendors may be tempted to advertise below realistic expectations to generate inquiry, then raise price guides once bidding starts. REAStats suburb data illustrates how uneven conditions are across NSW. Randwick currently records a 73.5% auction clearance rate with a $2,400,000 median and 23 days on market, while Port Macquarie — in the same state — clears at just 46% with an $850,000 median and 48 days on market. That is a 27.5-point gap in clearance rates within a single state.
Randwick's 73.5% clearance rate against Port Macquarie's 46% exposes a 27.5-percentage-point gap within a single state.
Kirribilli (72.5% clearance, $2,650,000 median) and Surry Hills (73% clearance, $1,920,000 median) sit in the same high-clearance bracket as Randwick, all with days-on-market figures in the low-to-mid 20s. Readers wanting the mechanics behind this behaviour can review REAStats' auction underquoting explainer, which covers state-by-state rules and how the practice can distort published clearance statistics.
Victoria's Model Versus NSW's Retreat
NSW's paused laws were modelled on Victoria, where sellers must now disclose their reserve price at least one week before auction and agents must publish sale prices after settlement. Those Victorian transparency measures remain in force even as NSW steps back from its own version.
Vendors and agents comparing quoting rules across state lines can review REAStats' state-by-state agent fee guide and the broader explainer on how agent commissions work for further context on how fee structures and price-guide obligations are disclosed in each state.
What the Suburb Data Shows
REAStats suburb data points to a wide range of conditions across the national market. Dandenong, with a $680,000 median and a 56% clearance rate against 40 days on market, sits at the slower end of that range. Nedlands in WA — outside NSW's jurisdiction, but included here for comparison — clears in just 15 days at a $2,200,000 median with 15% annual growth, among the fastest sales cycles in the REAStats data set.
The gap between fast-clearing NSW suburbs such as Randwick, Kirribilli and Surry Hills and slower-moving markets such as Dandenong and Port Macquarie reflects how differently conditions vary within the same state, even as NSW's enforcement pause applies uniformly across all of them.
What This Signals for Agents, Buyers and Vendors
For agents, the pause removes an immediate compliance burden for up to a year. For vendors, it creates short-term flexibility to adjust advertised prices without the threat of fines tied to three times commission, in a market where Sydney values have already dropped 10.1% from peak. Readers assessing an agent's quoting behaviour against actual sale outcomes can use REAStats' guide on choosing the right real estate agent to benchmark performance data before signing an agency agreement. The pause is due to last for up to a year, with a state election set for March and One Nation polling at 26% of the primary vote in NSW according to an October Resolve poll.


